For anyone who uses a crossbow, deciding between mechanical and fixed broadheads is an important decision. Mechanical broadheads are designed to open upon impact and cut a larger hole, while fixed broadheads are designed to hold their shape and penetrate deep into the target. Each type of broadhead has advantages and disadvantages that must be taken into consideration when making a choice. In this article, we will explore the differences between mechanical and fixed broadheads and help you decide which type is best for your hunting needs.

Mechanical vs Fixed Broadheads Crossbow – Explaining the Basics

Mechanical and fixed broadheads are two different types of broadheads used with crossbows. The main difference between the two is in the way they deploy.

Mechanical broadheads, also known as expandable broadheads, open up or expand when they hit the target. This makes them more effective at cutting through tissue and bone, resulting in more efficient kills. They are also more accurate because the blades can be adjusted for different distances. However, mechanical broadheads tend to be more expensive than fixed broadheads.

On the other hand, fixed broadheads are just a single piece of steel that doesn’t open up when it hits the target. They are generally less expensive than mechanical broadheads, but they don’t cut as well. Fixed broadheads often require more accurate shooting in order to be effective.

When choosing between mechanical and fixed broadheads, the most important factor is your shooting ability. If you are a more accurate shooter, then mechanical broadheads may be the best choice. But if you are a less accurate shooter, then fixed broadheads may be a better option.

Mechanical Vs Fixed Broadheads Crossbow
Mechanical Vs Fixed Broadheads Crossbow

Benefits of Using Mechanical Broadheads for Crossbow Hunting

The use of mechanical broadheads for crossbow hunting has many benefits, both to the hunter and to the environment. Mechanical broadheads offer greater accuracy than their fixed counterparts, as their design allows for more precise adjustment of trajectory and flight path. This can make the difference between a successful shot and a miss, especially when hunting in dense foliage or other challenging conditions. Additionally, mechanical broadheads are generally constructed of lighter materials than fixed broadheads, allowing for increased maneuverability and speed when drawing the bowstring.

Another advantage of using mechanical broadheads is that they are easier to maintain than fixed-blade versions. A mechanical broadhead requires no sharpening or honing, making it much easier to transport and store. Additionally, the components of a mechanical broadhead can be replaced easily, and there is no risk of damaging the cutting edge of the blade or having to worry about proper sharpening techniques. This can save the hunter time and money in the long run.

Finally, mechanical broadheads are also much more environmentally friendly than fixed broadheads, as they are designed to break apart upon impact with the target. This prevents the broadhead from becoming lodged in the animal, which can cause injury and a slow, painful death. Additionally, the broadhead pieces will decompose quickly, leaving minimal impact on the environment.

Benefits of Using Fixed Broadheads for Crossbow Hunting

Fixed broadheads are an essential tool for any crossbow hunter. They are designed to deliver maximum penetration and accuracy, ensuring a clean, humane kill. Fixed broadheads are available in a variety of sizes, allowing the hunter to choose the right size for the species they are hunting. Fixed broadheads are also preferred by archers because of their increased accuracy. Due to their design, fixed broadheads are less likely to be deflected by wind or brush than other types of broadheads. This makes them especially advantageous when hunting in dense brush.

Fixed broadheads also offer more consistent penetration than expandable broadheads, giving the hunter more reliable performance. Fixed broadheads also penetrate deeper, making them ideal for large game such as elk, moose, and bear. This increased penetration will help ensure a humane kill and reduce wounding loss.

Finally, fixed broadheads are typically more durable than expandable broadheads, making them a good option for long-term use. Fixed broadheads typically retain their shape and performance even after multiple uses, ensuring reliable performance for years to come.

Comparison of Mechanical vs Fixed Broadheads for Crossbow Hunting

Mechanical broadheads are an increasingly popular choice for crossbow hunting. They offer a number of advantages over fixed broadheads, including increased accuracy, increased penetration, and improved flight characteristics. On the other hand, fixed broadheads offer a more traditional hunting experience and are often preferred by more experienced hunters.

Mechanical broadheads are preferred by many hunters for their increased accuracy. This is due to the fact that mechanical broadheads open up upon impact, creating a larger cutting diameter and allowing for improved accuracy. Additionally, mechanical broadheads have improved penetration due to their increased cutting diameter. This increased penetration can be especially beneficial when hunting large game such as elk or moose. Finally, mechanical broadheads have improved flight characteristics compared to fixed broadheads, allowing for greater accuracy over long distances.

Despite these advantages, some hunters may prefer the more traditional experience offered by fixed broadheads. Fixed broadheads provide a more traditional hunting feel, and experienced hunters may prefer their tried and true performance. Additionally, fixed broadheads require less maintenance than mechanical broadheads, as they do not need to be regularly serviced or replaced.

Ultimately, the choice between mechanical and fixed broadheads for crossbow hunting comes down to personal preference. Mechanical broadheads offer a number of advantages over fixed broadheads, but experienced hunters may still prefer the traditional feel of fixed broadheads. Ultimately, both types of broadheads can be effective when hunting with a crossbow.

Tips for Making the Most of Your Mechanical or Fixed Broadheads Crossbow

When using mechanical or fixed broadheads for crossbow hunting, there are a few tips to keep in mind in order to maximize their effectiveness. First, make sure to practice with the broadheads prior to hunting season. This will help you to get used to their flight and trajectories, as well as get familiar with their accuracy. Second, select the correct broadhead for the job. Different broadheads are designed for different game, and selecting the right one will ensure you get the best results. Third, make sure to inspect your broadheads before each hunt. This will ensure that they are in good condition and will perform as expected.

Finally, take the time to properly adjust your crossbow’s sights. This will help ensure that your broadheads will hit their target. Following these tips will help you make the most of your mechanical or fixed broadheads when crossbow hunting.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Using Mechanical or Fixed Broadheads Crossbow

When using mechanical or fixed broadheads crossbow, there are a few common mistakes to avoid. Firstly, it is important to ensure that the broadhead is properly secured on the crossbow bolt. If it is not securely fastened, it could potentially cause the arrow to fly erratically or even become lodged in the target. It is also important to make sure that the blades of the mechanical or fixed broadhead are sharp enough to penetrate the target. If they are dull, they will not create the desired cutting effect and may not penetrate the target.

Additionally, it is important to adjust the sight of the crossbow so that it is properly aligned with the trajectory of the arrow. If it is not set properly, the arrow may fly off-target or not reach its intended distance. Lastly, it is important to practice with the broadhead and crossbow before taking it into the field. This will help ensure that the shooter is familiar and comfortable with the equipment and will be able to reliably hit their target.

Frequently Asked Questions[FAQs]

What is the difference between mechanical and fixed broadheads for crossbows?

Mechanical broadheads are designed to open upon impact with the target, creating a larger wound channel, while fixed broadheads remain in a closed position until impact. Mechanical broadheads usually feature a much larger cutting diameter than fixed broadheads, and this larger cut diameter can lead to more effective and efficient kills. Fixed broadheads, on the other hand, are designed with a much narrower cutting diameter and are typically more accurate due to the smaller cutting surface.

What type of broadhead is best for hunting game?

The type of broadhead that is best for hunting game depends on the type of game and the environment in which the hunt is taking place. If hunting in a densely wooded area, a larger cutting diameter provided by mechanical broadheads can be beneficial for deeper penetration and larger wound channel. If hunting in an open field, the accuracy of fixed broadheads may be more beneficial.

Are mechanical broadheads more accurate than fixed broadheads?

Generally, fixed broadheads are more accurate than mechanical broadheads due to the smaller cutting diameter. However, some mechanical broadheads feature accuracy-enhancing features such as adjustable blades and cut-on-contact tips to increase accuracy.

What type of broadhead is best for target shooting?

For target shooting, a fixed broadhead is generally the best option. Fixed broadheads are designed with a much narrower cutting diameter and are typically more accurate due to the smaller cutting surface.

What type of broadhead is best for small game such as rabbits and squirrels?

For small game such as rabbits and squirrels, a mechanical broadhead is usually the best option. Mechanical broadheads are designed to open upon impact with the target, creating a larger wound channel, which is ideal for smaller game animals.

Does the type of broadhead affect the speed of the arrow?

Yes, the type of broadhead can affect the speed of the arrow. Mechanical broadheads are usually heavier than fixed broadheads and can slow the arrow down. Additionally, the cutting diameter of the broadhead can also have an effect on the speed of the arrow as larger cutting diameters will create more drag.

Can mechanical broadheads be used with a crossbow?

Yes, mechanical broadheads can be used with a crossbow. However, it is important to check the manufacturer’s specifications to ensure the broadhead is compatible with the crossbow.

Are mechanical broadheads more expensive than fixed broadheads?

Generally, mechanical broadheads are more expensive than fixed broadheads due to their increased complexity and the additional components required for their construction.


The Mechanical Vs Fixed Broadheads Crossbow debate is an ongoing one, and ultimately, the decision of which type of broadhead to use is up to the individual hunter. Both types offer advantages and disadvantages and are equally capable of harvesting game when used properly. Ultimately, it is important to choose the type of broadhead that best fits your individual hunting style and conditions.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *